Be brutally honest about these lamps.

Remember the post about these lamps?

Well I'm on round 2 of trying to update them and I am failing. 

At first I painted them in Bon Voyage in high gloss and while the color was pretty most of the details were lost.

(Sorry I don't have pictures of them like that)

So then I tried this. 

To some extent I like them, but I'm afraid they look like a paint by number project.

What do you think?

Be 100% honest, you won't hurt my feelings. :)